take a brow
In one of my recent subscription boxes, I received a travel-size version of It Cosmetic's Brow Power Universal Eyebrow Pencil. I typically use powder and gel on my eyebrows, but not often pencil. I feel like it's harder to make pencil look natural. That hasn't been a problem with this pencil, though, and it has quickly become part of my daily routine.
For the record, it's difficult to take pictures of your own eyebrows.
I would recommend It Cosmetics as a go-to brand any time you're in the market for a new brow pencil, but I would particularly encourage you to give this one a try.